Humidifier vs Vaporizer

Humidifier
Vaporizer

When trying to choose a vaporizer or humidifier for protection against cold climates, allergies, nosebleeds or any sort of cold symptoms, it is important to understand the differences between the mode of operation of these appliances. A vaporizer is just like a warm mist humidifier in that it heats water to release vapor. Inhalants like Vicks VapoRub can also be added to vaporizers and certain humidifiers to ease congestion. They are especially useful for babies.

Comparison chart

Edit this comparison chart

Humidifier

Vaporizer

Purpose To increase the moisture content in the surrounding area. To inhale extracts of plants or other sources for coldand health benefits.
Usage During winter or when the air is cold and dry in either a single room or the entire house. Appliance used to extract herbs and plant essences for inhalation. It creates moisture by boiling water.
Process Make water vapor using a rapidly turning disk submerged in water A heating element creates steam
Heated No Yes – risk of burn
Release of vapor A humidifier emits cold vapors. A vaporizer emits hot vapors.
Cleaning Daily Daily
Chance of spreading bacteria Yes. Water does not boil and so there are increased chances for spread of bacteria or molds. No.Less risk of spreading molds or bacteria.
Application Suitable to moisten dry skin and nasal passages that dry up due to common cold. Humidifier works best in children’s room. Not suitable when children are around since it could be accident prone.
Cost More expensive Cheaper
Water type Distilled preferable Tap is OK
Effectiveness The same The same
Noise Noisier Less noisy
Add medication No Yes
Accessories No external objects can be added. Inhalants can be added in order to facilitate breathing.

Contents: Humidifier vs Vaporizer

A kid enjoying a humidifier
A kid enjoying a humidifier

edit Mode of Operation

Humidifiers are appliances that are used to humidify or moisten the air in a room. During cool climates, when the air becomes dry and breathing becomes difficult, a humidifier releases cool vapors and releases moisture to the room. The cool water vapors are created by using a rapidly turning disk, submerged in water.

Vaporizers add humidity to the air by creating steam. Water is boiled in a vaporizer and hot vapors are emitted into the room. Inhalants can be added to the vaporizer device but this cannot be done to the humidifier.

Neither humidifiers nor vaporizers really purify the air as such.

edit Varieties

There are several types of humidifier. A central humidifier can be hooked up to the house’s heating equipment, receiving water directly and humidifying the whole house, while a tabletop or room humidifier is smaller and must be filled manually. Varieties also include evaporative, which capture all minerals and pollutants, ultrasonic, which create vapor using sound waves, and cool mist, which use a spinning disk and are both cheaper and more common.

Crane Ultrasonic Drop Shape Cool Mist Humidifier
Crane Ultrasonic Drop Shape Cool Mist Humidifier
Vicks Warm Mist Humidifier
Vicks Warm Mist Humidifier
Vaporizer
Vaporizer

Varieties of vaporizer include portable vaporizers (which can be handheld) and electric vaporizers that plug into the mains. Vaporizers are also classified by the way they heat the substance:

edit Applications

Humidifiers and vaporizers are both used to add humidity to a dry room. They combat excessive dryness in winter, preventing build-up of static electricity and dry skin and lips, and helping to prevent infants and young children from developing breathing problems and infections due to the dry air. They can also help relieve the symptoms of allergies or the common cold, and in some cases those of asthma or bronchitis.

In this video Pediatrician Dr. Ari Brown discusses whether it is helpful to use a humidifier or a vaporizer for a child's health. It further discusses some of the common used brands of humidifier:

edit Allergies

Both humidifiers and vaporizers can help ease allergies. Some people find the cool mist produced by a humidifier easier to tolerate.

Medication such as VapoRub can also be added to vaporizers to help ease breathing.

edit Risks

Humidifiers can be a breeding ground for mold and bacteria, especially when relative humidity is over 60%. Humidifiers should be cleaned every day. They can also disperse minerals in tap water, and so should only be used with distilled water. A vaporizer does not carry such risk because it boils water before emitting vapor. Mold and bacteria are destroyed when the water boils. Steam also does not contain minerals.

Vaporizers are dangerous when children are around since boiling water could spill when knocked over and cause physical damage. Hot steam could also prove hazardous to those who are ignorant of the fact.

Both vaporizers and humidifiers must be cleaned every day.

edit Cost

In general, humidifiers are more expensive than vaporizers. Humidifiers also need replacement filters or wicks.

edit Why Choose One Over the Other

People with young children may prefer a humidifier to a vaporizer, as vaporizers can cause scalds if knocked over. However, medication can be added to vaporizers, making them a good choice for those suffering with breathing difficulties.

edit References

Comments: Humidifier vs Vaporizer

Your IP address will be logged and parts of it shown publicly.
Write <youtube v=YouTubeVideoID /> to embed a YouTube video in your comment.
Comments with links (URLs) are not allowed because we get overrun by spam.

March 23, 2014, 4:25pm

There is a such thing as a warm mist humidiifier, which is recommended for colds. They are sold at your local pharmacy. Id like to see the difference between those two.

— 172.✗.✗.19
0

March 12, 2014, 9:44pm

What is the best description of one that is an" active humidification device"?

— 75.✗.✗.32
0
Stay informed Related Comparisons
Follow Diffen
Make Diffen Smarter.

Log in to edit comparisons or create new comparisons in your area of expertise!

Sign up »
Top 5 Comparisons Recently Compared

share

Up next

Common Cold vs. Flu