American Football vs. Rugby

American Football
Rugby

American football is a game played between two teams and consists of 11 players in each of the two teams, with unlimited substitutions. American football is a game of intense physical play with complex strategy to score points by advancing the ball to the opponent team’s end-zone.

Rugby is best described as a blend of the contact of American football, the running of soccer, and the transition of basketball. It is a game played between two teams with 15 players in each, played on a rectangular field, with the object being to run with an oval ball across the opponent’s goal line or kick it through the upper portion of the goal posts.

Both the games differ in a variety of parameters.

Comparison chart

Edit this comparison chart

American Football

User Rating (1218):

Rugby

User Rating (1179):
Time limit Four 15-minute quarters, with a half-time intermission after the second quarter. The game clock stops frequently between plays. Two 40 minute halves with a ten minute half time. Clock only stops for prolonged injuries.
Object of the Game Object of the game is to score points by carrying the ball beyond the opponents touch line. (Each such instance is called a touch down). Also scoring by kicking it between the goal post called a Field Goal. Object of the game is to carry the ball and place the ball down on the opponents touch line (called a Try) or kick it between the goal posts.
Number of players 11 players on the field at any point of time Team consists of 15 players for Union
Major League National Football League (NFL) Major comps include"(domestic) super 15, Aviva prem, RFU, top 14, Nat league 1 & 2, rugby pro d2, ITM cup, currie cup, rebo pro d12, super 10, shut shield, NSW suburb rugby(+more) (internation) RWC, four nat, six nat, pacific nat, asian 5 nat(+more)
Substitution Unlimited Up to 7 substitutions allowed (depending on the tournament rules) Once pulled out cannot be substituted back in unless there is an injury and no other substitutes.
Countries USA Worldwide
Player Size NFL player brandon banks 70 kg. (155 lbs.) was at one point 67 kg. (149 lbs.) is the lightest NFL player since 2010 while the largest NFL player was 162.3kg (358 lbs.) The largest running back is 122kg (268 lbs.) Brandon jacobs. The lightest rugby player to ever play international rugby was Gordon McGhie at just 58kg. largest rugby international bill cavubati (165.3kg) his heaviest at 201.7kg (442.5lbs).
Ball A prolate spheroid which is about 11 inches (28 cm) long and about 22 inches (56 cm) in circumference at the center and weighs around 0.875lbs. A prolate spheroid shaped football. The accepted international size is called the "size 5" and is approximately 27 cm long and 60 cm in circumference at its widest point and weighs around 1lb.
Number of Umpires / Referees 3 to 6 referees plus booth review 4 referees including TMO (television match official) who declares tries valid or invalid via cameras for tries which aren't visible for the ref or caused after an illegal infringement and 2 assistant referees.
Current World Champions Seattle Seahawks (2013-2014) New Zealand All Blacks (Rugby Union World Cup)
Field Length: 120 yards (109.728 meters) in total (100 yards (91.44 meters) of playing field, with two 10-yard (9.144 meters) end zones) Width: 160 feet (48.768 meters) 100 (120m if end zone "goal area" is included) meters long by 70 meters wide with 20-meter in try area.
Protective gear Helmet, Shoulder/Chest pad/protector, upper leg padding and mouthguard are rightfully required. Players are only allowed modest padding on Head, Shoulders, Collarbone etc. Only a mouthguard is required.
Major Tournaments NFL Playoffs Rugby World Cup
What is it? American football is a game with intense physical aggression with players that have speed, power, and explosiveness that requires helmets and padding to be worn. Rugby is a game with intense physical aggression and necessary endurance that only requires a mouth guard for play. Certain possesions require speed and agility, others require strength.
Average contact per game Average tackles per game per player: 4 with highest recorded at 4600lbs (by sports science), consistent contact away from the ball with downfield blocking with contact as severe as a tackle. Average tackles per game per player: 16 - Average hit impact: 1600lbs. of force (recorded from members of the LA rugby team by sports science)

Contents: American Football vs Rugby

edit Differences in rules of Rugby and American Football

American football: Each team has 11 players on the field at one time, with unlimited substitutions. Each team gets three time-outs per half. Play begins with a kickoff. Two teams line up opposite each other; they are usually lining up a “play from scrimmage.” Receiving player may run with ball or may pass it. Each team has to move the ball at least 10 yards within 4 downs. If they fail to do so, other team gets the chance. If they succeed they get 4 new tries to move the ball 10 yards further. The main object is to score points by advancing the pointed oval-shaped ball into the opponent’s team end-zone.

Rugby: A Rugby team consists of 15 players, divided into forwards and backs. Forwards are often larger and stronger players of the team having their main job to win the possession of the ball. The backs are usually smaller, faster, and more agile and exploit the ball possessions. The match begins with a kickoff and the teams compete for possession. The player of the receiving team may run with the ball, or kick it, or pass it to any other player laterally or behind him. Opponent player may tackle the ball carrier at any time. Other than tackles, scrummages, rucks, mauls, and lineouts, no other contact is allowed. Even dangerous tackles are not permitted and are penalized severely. Once tackled, the player must release the ball immediately so play may continue. Once a team has crossed the opposing team’s goal line and touched the ball to the ground, a try is scored (five points). After each try, the scoring team has the opportunity to score two more points with a conversion.

edit Origin of rugby and football

American football is said to have developed from Rugby. British colonists from Canada are said to have brought rugby to the Americans. At that time the two were not as differentiated as now.

The origin of Rugby in England goes back long into the 19th century and even earlier. In 1800's formalities were introduced to football rules in the seven major public schools of England.Handling the ball was permitted in football in the early 1800's when players were allowed to take a mark and then a free kick. The Rugby Football Union had been formed in 1871 by representatives of 21 clubs - all of which were located in southern England and most were within London. By the early 1890's rugby was widespread and well over half the RFU's clubs were in northern England. The working classes of the north of England and South Wales were particularly taken with rugby over football (soccer).

All sports historians place the beginning of American Football from Rugby. It is said that the Britishers got the game to Canada in late 19th century which then spread to America. Here many variations were made to the game and in 1892 the roots of professional American football can be traced. From here on this game started getting its own identity.

edit Playing Field

American football is played on a rectangular field 120 yards (110 meters) long by 53 1/3 yards (49 meters) wide. Near each end of the field is a goal line; they are 100 yards apart. A rugby league field is very similar, it is 120 metres long and about half that in width, there is a line across the field every ten metres.

edit Contact Sport

The most significant differences between American and Rugby football are that in Rugby all players are allowed to handle the ball and any sort of blocking, forward passing, and time-outs are not allowed. Unlike American football, in case of Rugby any kind of screening and obstruction to players who do not have the ball is not allowed. This is the main reason why Rugby is much safer than American football. Unlike American football, only lateral passes are legal, and running and kicking can advance the ball.  In American Football, one forward pass per down is permitted, so long as it originates behind the line of scrimmage.

edit Protective Equipment in rugby and football

In Rugby, there is lack of hard protective equipments such as helmet and padding. That’s why in case of Rugby players are also taught to tackle with personal safety in mind. In football, hard tackles are allowed which is why there is padding.

edit Schedule and Cost

Rugby provides for a more flexible schedule and less costly athletic team than professional football, hockey, or other options.

edit Control

In case of Rugby, players are concerned more about retaining ball possession rather than gaining yardage as in case of American football.

edit Scoring

A touchdown is the American football equivalent of rugby league's try. Ironically, a try requires the ball to be 'touched down' to the ground, whereas a touchdown doesn't. In American football it is sufficient for the player carrying the ball to cause the ball to enter the end zone (in-goal area) while still in bounds, by carrying it in or holding the ball in or through the imaginary plane of the goal line. In rugby league the ball must be pressed to the ground in the in-goal area. An American football touchdown scores 6 points and a rugby league try is now worth 4 points. In rugby union a try is worth 5 points, the conversion is worth 2.

edit Football vs Rugby Strategy

American football is a game of set moves and counter moves (similar to chess). On the other hand, Rugby is a more free-flowing spontaneous game.

edit Geographical differences

As the name suggests, American football is played in North America while rugby is played across the globe with prominence in South Africa, New Zealand, Australia and parts of Europe.

edit References

Share this comparison:

If you read this far, you should follow us:

"American Football vs Rugby." Diffen.com. Diffen LLC, n.d. Web. 25 Nov 2014. < http://www.diffen.com/difference/American_Football_vs_Rugby >

Related Comparisons Follow Diffen
Make Diffen Smarter.

Log in to edit comparisons or create new comparisons in your area of expertise!

Sign up »
Top 5 Comparisons

Comments: American Football vs Rugby

Comments via Facebook

Anonymous comments (15)

February 3, 2014, 9:14am

I really don't get why everyone here is subtly putting football down and lifting rugby up on a pedestal? I am not American - I come from a nation that plays rugby, albeit not as big to us in the way football is to the Americans. I do, however, love football. But who are you to say that football players are 'less tough' than rugby players? Football is really dangerous as well, not what I'd call a wuss' sport. Each sport is their own, I don't get why people are saying rugby is 'more special' than football. That is all subjective.

— 220.✗.✗.18
6

February 14, 2011, 11:18pm

Game flow is important. As American football tends to be organised in very violent in small bursts, rugby is more a game of attrition - 40 minutes of almost non-stop play. American football has more dangerous tackles, hence the padding, but I personally find rugby better to watch as I find the breaks between plays in American football infuriating.

— 68.✗.✗.179
6

April 12, 2014, 11:35am

There is much more technique in tackling in rugby than in AF but they are both great sports-better than soccer football!!

— 78.✗.✗.240
4

March 11, 2013, 12:26am

for those of you saying AF is for pussies i play both and football seems to hurt a lot more

— 47.✗.✗.10
4

July 31, 2013, 2:57pm

Jonah Lomu Height 1.96 m (6 ft 5 in) Weight 120 kg (265 lb; 18 st 13 lb) a former New Zealand rugby union player is comparable or certainly fitter than most quarterbacks even the likes of Peyton Manning. I certainly would like to see any NFL player play a full game of rugby with out the stoppages and time outs. In all honestly thay could not do it. In all fairness you can not really compare rugby to gridiron. They're two different games although gridiron has its roots in rugby today it is a different game.

— 50.✗.✗.4
1

March 25, 2014, 4:46pm

Actually the heaviest football player ever was 410 pounds(Aaron Gibson)thank you very much.

— 107.✗.✗.89
0

February 5, 2011, 10:28pm

I don't understand how someone can say this is a biased report. They are simply facts on each sport. You perceive it based on what you like more to be biased towards that sport, it is pretty objective in nature.

— 96.✗.✗.60
0

April 12, 2014, 11:32am

Also the hit up power stats were recorded by the LA rugby team but the AF stats by an international team.

— 78.✗.✗.240
-1

March 8, 2014, 7:47am

Ridiculous. Rugby players make more tackles, with no padding! In both games the opposition runs at the defence at full speed. To say the impact in American football is 3 times more is just American ego. Rugby league is even tougher. Google ' state of origin' , and tell me the hits are soft!

— 203.✗.✗.210
-1

February 3, 2014, 9:21am

Lol you jerkwads insulting football sound really immature. (not an American)

— 220.✗.✗.36
-1

December 18, 2013, 4:20pm

NFL players would not be able to tackle harder or be more physical than a rugby player in a rugby match given the ruleset in that sport.As well,they would be afraid of breaking their necks with faulty techniques and scrummaging.Simple they wont be good enough to play rugby generally.Similarly rugby players wont be top dogs at nfl...sure many will be able to succeed but wont usurp specialists in that sport.Also.NFL players are massively pumped up with steroids and growth hormones,etc...some rugby players as well but not many...overall take your pick....i prefer rugby as it is far more fluid,faster and flows better.NFL seems very mechanised and stop start.

— 197.✗.✗.157
-1

December 18, 2013, 5:55am

Rugby is the best

— 76.✗.✗.36
-1

December 12, 2013, 9:22pm

In rugby you get paralyze and other injury because of contact hard and hard tackle and hard run but to avoid it you have to be smart and experience but American football it's mostly head injury because they don't have experience in how to tackle how to run sidestep or avoid it, and because they are not that fit to with stand it or smart enough

— 76.✗.✗.36
-1

December 12, 2013, 9:11pm

Rugby is more dangerous and hard that's why is international , American football not enough danger and not hard enough that's why only local

— 76.✗.✗.36
-1

October 29, 2013, 12:25pm

Lol according to sports station if Ray Lewis tackled someone without any gear on he would shatter their ribs. So dont even say football players are weak NFL FTW.

— 65.✗.✗.5
-1

share

Up next

AFC vs. NFC