Cubic Zirconia vs. Diamond

Cubic Zirconia
Diamond

Although very different in other properties, cubic zirconia and diamond appear similar to a lay person because of their outer appearance and high refractive index. Fact is, diamond is a very expensive, naturally occurring substance, whereas cubic zirconia is manufactured and a less expensive jewelry substitute for diamonds.

Comparison chart

Edit this comparison chart

Cubic Zirconia

User Rating (125):

Diamond

User Rating (100):
Definition Cubic zirconia (or CZ), the cubic crystalline form of zirconium dioxide (ZrO2), is a mineral that is widely synthesized for use as a diamond simulant Diamond is a natural mineral, an allotrope of carbon.
Cost Low cost High
Color Since CZ are synthetic, they can be made absolutely colorless Diamonds usually have a yellow or brown tinge, the truly colorless diamonds are very rare.
Use Mainly as a gemstone, as it bears high similarity to diamond Jewelry; industrial purposes – high-pressure experiments, cutting tools.
Hardness Relatively hard, though nowhere near diamond but harder than most natural gemstones found. 8.5 on Mohs hardness scale Extremely hard (10 on Mohs scale). The hardest known natural material.
Luster Adamantine Adamantine
Material Synthetic Natural
Dispersion 0.060 (higher than diamond) 0.044 (lower than cubic zirconium and moissante)
Crystal system Tetragonal; 4/m 2/m Hexoctahedral (cubic)
Crystal habit Dipyramidal prismatic Isometric, Octahedral
Chemical formula ZrO2 C
Refractive Index 2.176 2.417
Thermal conductivity CZ are thermal insulators Diamonds are among the most efficient thermal conductors
Specific gravity The specific gravity of CZ is between 5.6 to 6 and is relatively 1.7 times more than that of a diamond of the same size Diamond has a specific gravity of 3.52
Density Between 5.5 and 5.9 3.5 – 3.53
Flaws production of cubic zirconia is virtually flawless Diamonds definitely have some kind of flaw
Melting Point 2750 C (4976 F) 3550 C (6422 F)
Cut In CZ, the shape of the facet is sometimes different from that of a diamond Diamonds can be of various cuts

Contents: Cubic Zirconia vs Diamond

edit Overview

Diamond is an allotrope of carbon. It is the hardest known natural substance. Its hardness and high dispersion of light make it useful for industrial applications and jewelry. Diamonds make excellent abrasives because they can be scratched only by other diamonds. Because all these qualities and its rare natural occurence, the cost of diamonds is very high.

To substitute expensive diamonds in jewelry, a cheaper alternative was found to be Cubic zirconia as a commom man would call it. CZ is the cubic crystalline form of zirconium dioxide(ZrO2), is a mineral that is widely synthesized for use as a diamond simulant. The synthesized material is hard, optically flawless and usually colorless, but may be made in a variety of different colors. It has close visual likeness to diamond and is relatively cheaper.

A bracelet with cubic zirconia.
A bracelet with cubic zirconia.

Browse and buy cubic zirconia jewelry

Shop for diamond jewelry

edit Properties

edit Hardness

Diamond is the hardest natural material known to man, it measures upto a perfect 10 on the Mohs’ hardness scale. They are good abrasives and can be scratched only by other diamonds. This quality is useful in its use as jewelry. Industrial use of diamonds has historically also been associated with their hardness, it can be used to polish, cut, or wear away any material, including other diamonds. Cubic zirconia are also relatively hard as compared to other gemstones though its hardness cannot measure anywhere close to diamonds. On the Mohs’ scale it is 8.5.

edit Electrical and Thermal Conductivity

Diamonds are electric insulators and excellent thermal conductors. Cubic Zirconia are thermal insulators.

edit Color

Diamonds are generally found with a yellow or brown tinge in them, this is due to the nitrogen[1] found in them. The color depends on the concentration of nitrogen or other such subsitutes in the diamond. The really colorless diamonds are the ones which are free of any flaws and usually rare. Cubic Zirconia on the other hand being a synthesised product, can be made absolutely colorless. It can be given the grade ‘D’ which is the best quality diamond on the diamonds color grading scale.

edit Dispersion

Dispersion of Cubic Zirconia is higher than diamond making the prismatic fire more intense in it. Diamond dispersion is 0.044 while CZ is 0.060.

edit Specific Gravity

Cubic zirconia crystals are heavyweights in comparison to diamonds; a cubic zirconia will weigh about 1.7 times more than a diamond of equivalent size.

edit Refractive Index

The refractive index of cubic zirconia is lower than that of a diamond. It has a refractive index of 2.176, compared to a diamond's 2.417.

edit Flaws

All diamonds have some kind of defect, it can be a feather, an included crystal or a remnant of an original crystal face (e.g. trigons). Cubic zirconia on the other hand are synthetic and hance are virtually flawless.

edit History

The Imperial State Crown is known to have ‎2,868 Diamonds
The Imperial State Crown is known to have ‎2,868 Diamonds

Diamonds are a natural material and are thought to have been first recognized and mined in India (Golconda being one of the first places), where significant alluvial deposits of the stone could then be found along the rivers Penner, Krishna and Godavari. In the twentieth century, experts in the field of gemology have developed methods of grading diamonds and other gemstones based on the characteristics most important to their value as a gem. Four characteristics, known informally as the four Cs, are now commonly used as the basic descriptors of diamonds: these are carat, cut, color, and clarity.

Cubic Zirconia is not a natural material but is a synthesized form of zirconium oxide which was extracted from the mineral baddeleyite. It has diamond look alike properties.


edit Formation (Diamond) and Manufacturing (Cubi Zirconia)

The formation of natural diamond requires very specific conditions. Diamond formation requires exposure of carbon-bearing materials to high pressure, ranging approximately between 45 and 60 kilobars, but at a comparatively low temperature range between approximately 1652–2372 °F (900–1300 °C). The depths of craters in which diamonds are formed are estimated to be in between 140–190 kilometers (90–120 miles) though sometimes it can be much more than this too. Long residence in the cratonic lithosphereallows diamond crystals to grow larger.

Cubic zirconia on the other hand is a man made product. Baddeleyite was discovered in 1892, the yellowish monoclinic mineral baddeleyite is a natural form of zirconium oxide. In 1930, stabilized zirconia was obtained after stabilization of zirconium oxide had been realized. Seven years later, German mineralogists discovered naturally occurring cubic zirconia in the form of microscopic grains included in metamict zircon. As with the majority of grown diamond look-alikes, the conceptual birth of single-crystal cubic zirconia began in the minds of scientists but it was later in 1960s in France when research into controlled single-crystal growth of cubic zirconia occurred. The Soviets later perfected the method and called it skull crucible and named the jewel, fianit, though the name was not used world wide. Their breakthrough was published in 1973, and commercial production began in 1976. By 1980 annual global production had reached 50 million carats (10,000 kg). The method is still used today with some variation.

edit Price

Due to the qualities of diamonds and their rarity, the cost of diamonds is very high. CZ is relatively cheaper. As a diamond simulation, CZ only has competition from the recently discover moissanite. While a flawless 1 carat diamond would cost about $7000 or more, a flawless 1 carat CZ can be purchased for less than $10.

Also see:

edit Production

Gem production totals nearly 30 million carats (6,000 kg) of cut and polished stones annually, and over 100 million carats (20,000 kg) of mined diamonds are sold for industrial use each year, as are about 100,000 kg of synthesized diamond. De Beers owns or controls a significant portion of the world's rough diamond production facilities (mines) and distribution channels for gem-quality diamonds. De Beers and its subsidiaries own mines that produce some 40 percent of annual world diamond production. At one time it was thought over 80 percent of the world's rough diamonds passed through the Diamond Trading Company (DTC, a subsidiary of De Beers) in London, but presently the figure is estimated at less than 50 percent.

edit References

Share this comparison:

If you read this far, you should follow us on:

"Cubic Zirconia vs Diamond." Diffen.com. Diffen LLC, n.d. Web. 29 Jul 2014. < http://www.diffen.com/difference/Cubic_Zirconia_vs_Diamond >

Stay informed Related Comparisons
Follow Diffen
Make Diffen Smarter.

Log in to edit comparisons or create new comparisons in your area of expertise!

Sign up »
Top 5 Comparisons Recently Compared

Comments: Cubic Zirconia vs Diamond

Comments via Facebook

Anonymous comments (4)

October 30, 2013, 10:31am

If u don't know the difference between CZ and zircon how can anyone trust the info on your site.

— 24.✗.✗.28
0

August 16, 2011, 11:10am

As the previous commenter stated - cubic zirconia is not the same as zircon. In the chart above you define cubic zirconia as "the cubic crystalline form of zirconium dioxide (ZrO2)" which is correct, but then you give the chemical formula as "ZrSiO4" which is the formula for natural zircon (crystalline zirconium silicate).

— 74.✗.✗.246
0

January 21, 2011, 11:58am

Cubic Zirconia is not the same as Zircon, as Zircon is a completely different and natural gemstone.

— 87.✗.✗.58
0

January 3, 2011, 11:11pm

this is such a long research

— 75.✗.✗.62
0

share

Up next

Diamond vs. Moissanite